I had a similar encounter just now. My Paragon is barely holding together, dipping between 0CR and ~20%. Attacked the pirate plunder fleet because they'd have a buttload of supplies, got battered a bit from the massive outnumbering but otherwise killed enough combat ships to force a retreat. Send out salvage teams. Remaining active Tarsusseseses (what's the plural for those things?) didn't want to fly away, I wanted to disengage and that translated into "I want to abandon all the supplies I just sent out salvage crews for and fly away empty handed". Wait, wat? Hey, guise? Erm... We forgot the supplies, guise. Guise. *shrugs* Okay, fine, everyone's going hungry for a week, then.