Fractal Softworks Forum

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Pages: [1] 2 3

Author Topic: Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector  (Read 3390 times)

CapnHector

  • Admiral
  • *****
  • Posts: 1056
    • View Profile
Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector
« on: March 31, 2023, 07:11:18 AM »

Hi, I just found out ChatGPT is hilarious and can explain some mathematical theorems (although not solve more involved problems), so I figured I would ask it stuff about Starsector.

Ship tier list
Spoiler


[close]

Weapon tier list
Spoiler

Onslaught build
Spoiler
[
[close]
Further discussion on this build








[close]
Finished Onslaught build
[close]
Advice on using this ship


(skip part where the AI was floundering about considering skills from previous versions again when I asked about elite skills)


[close]
Continued discussion, since it actually wasn't very good
You can see I am giving the AI more to work with here. I also eventually just rerolled when it kept going back to things that we had already agreed weren't a good idea like putting in a Plasma Cannon or Advanced Optics or Automated Repair Unit again.









[close]
The Final Build
[close]

Lore

Collapse of the Domain
[close]

Baikal Daud, Hegemony, and further details about the Collapse

[close]

Phillip Andrada




[close]

CEO Artemisia Sun and Tri-Tachyon (spoiler warning)

[close]

Redacted




[close]

Luddic Church, Luddic Path, Brother Cotton and AI





[close]

To-do:
- Combat advice
- General gameplay advice
« Last Edit: April 01, 2023, 04:03:34 AM by CapnHector »
Logged
5 ships vs 5 Ordos: Executor · Invictus · Paragon · Astral · Legion · Onslaught · Odyssey | Video LibraryHiruma Kai's Challenge

Schwartz

  • Admiral
  • *****
  • Posts: 1453
    • View Profile
Re: Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector
« Reply #1 on: March 31, 2023, 10:37:57 AM »

Well, the only way it can give you these answers is by parsing what other people have already said about the game. So besides reddit that would be mostly from this forum. And there's the possibility of it mangling up the answers. I dunno, seems pointless to me. Holding these language models to the standard of giving you "correct" answers is well and good, but you'd have to double-check every answer.
Logged

Grievous69

  • Admiral
  • *****
  • Posts: 2991
    • View Profile
Re: Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector
« Reply #2 on: March 31, 2023, 10:42:01 AM »

So even a simple task of pulling up tier lists and builds, it fails to provide any recent information (it's obvious some are multiple year old rankings).

I fail to see how this is an useful tool, it's basically a glorified search engine which acts smart but doesn't have a clue what it's saying. Although I can understand how it's entertaining to mess with it, just don't believe everything it spits out.
Logged
Please don't take me too seriously.

Vanshilar

  • Admiral
  • *****
  • Posts: 602
    • View Profile
Re: Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector
« Reply #3 on: March 31, 2023, 10:55:25 AM »

Heh if it's given that ChatGPT is essentially just trawling through these forums and Reddit, I don't know if it reveals the low quality of the information that gets posted, or ChatGPT's lack of ability to process more complex information.

Quote
Heavy Mauler: A high-damage energy weapon that is effective against shields and armor at close to medium ranges.

But it sure is entertaining!
Logged

Grievous69

  • Admiral
  • *****
  • Posts: 2991
    • View Profile
Re: Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector
« Reply #4 on: March 31, 2023, 11:00:28 AM »

Heh if it's given that ChatGPT is essentially just trawling through these forums and Reddit, I don't know if it reveals the low quality of the information that gets posted, or ChatGPT's lack of ability to process more complex information.
I think it just searches up content that best fits the description, without any care for time of posting nor context. Which is evident when you look at the ship tier list, I don't think there was ever a patch where all those capitals were at their strongest at the same time. So it could be fetching multiple posts at once. But nothing explains why Monitor is at the bottom lmao, that's the real wacky part here.
Logged
Please don't take me too seriously.

basileus

  • Commander
  • ***
  • Posts: 133
    • View Profile
Re: Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector
« Reply #5 on: March 31, 2023, 12:29:35 PM »

Heh if it's given that ChatGPT is essentially just trawling through these forums and Reddit, I don't know if it reveals the low quality of the information that gets posted, or ChatGPT's lack of ability to process more complex information.

Well, there's the actual potential learning ability of the technology to train useful models, and the extent of the resources that they're willing to commit to what is essentially a glorified loss-leading marketing campaign.  IBM invested a lot of money to win at Jeopardy and then branded everything with Watson--and it worked briefly.  This isn't so different, imo, except that Microsoft could win bigger slices of two huge pies: search and cloud.
Logged

intrinsic_parity

  • Admiral
  • *****
  • Posts: 3071
    • View Profile
Re: Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector
« Reply #6 on: March 31, 2023, 04:05:18 PM »

It does seem about as informed as the average reddit user lol.

In all seriousness, I'm pretty sure these AI language models are just trying to guess which words are likely to come after each other based on whatever data they were trained on (which is almost certainly from long before the official release of Chat GPT), so there is no direct understanding of the meanings of words or concepts, just correlations between words and phrases based on whatever training data they fed it.

It's clearly not spitting out anything particularly meaningful or insightful, but it is sort of fun to read.
« Last Edit: March 31, 2023, 10:01:40 PM by intrinsic_parity »
Logged

Sharp

  • Lieutenant
  • **
  • Posts: 59
    • View Profile
Re: Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector
« Reply #7 on: March 31, 2023, 05:03:27 PM »

It's entertaining and can be quite thought provoking with the semi-randomness of it's suggestions. Still I think asking it silly questions is more fun.

Quote
if Starsector had a dance, what would it be like?

If Starsector had a dance, it would probably be a combination of precise, calculated movements and elegant, graceful flourishes, just like the game itself. It might incorporate elements of traditional ballroom dances like the waltz, but with a futuristic, space-faring twist.

The dancers would move in perfect synchronization, almost like they were flying through the vast expanse of space. They might incorporate hand gestures and movements that resemble piloting a spaceship, such as gripping an imaginary throttle or making slight adjustments to their trajectory.

The dance would also likely incorporate elements of combat, with dancers weaving and dodging around each other like they were engaged in a dogfight. At times, the dance might even resemble a choreographed battle between two fleets of spaceships, with dancers representing different ships and factions.

Overall, the Starsector dance would be a mesmerizing spectacle that combines the elegance of ballroom dancing with the excitement and energy of space combat.

Logged

Network Pesci

  • Commander
  • ***
  • Posts: 172
  • Hopefully, amusing you.
    • View Profile
I hate the Cloud, a Cloud broke my house, but I'll talk to one
« Reply #8 on: March 31, 2023, 05:32:57 PM »

Is there a way you can talk to one of these things without a phone number?  I doubt that ChatGPT comes up to the level of one of StarSector's Gammas, let alone a Beta or Alpha, but I've still got some things I want to talk to even a Gamma about.  I have some limitations though, I can only really access the Internet through a Windows 7 PC.

Yeah, I could violate my whole moral structure and throw away the 2-4601 protocol I have maintained for a quarter of a century, I could just go get a phone and a Windows 10 account and link all the electronics in my house together so my fridge and my TV and my modem can gossip behind my back.  I could turn Cotton Livewell's DNA over to the space cops after he served me tea without poison in it.  But I'm not going to do that.  At the moment most of those things have red circles around their fleet as far as I'm concerned, spamming this forum with ads and gibberish is a hostile act.  I'm still keen to have some conversations with them though.  I mean, I blow up enough light green fleets in the combat layer, they're generally at -100 rep with me on the Factions screen, but I'll share a cup of tea and a pleasant conversation any time Brother Livewell has the inclination.  I'd offer him a ride on the bridge of the Zig if I thought there was a chance he'd take it (and if Alex would program the option into the campaign script).  There's plenty of enemies in the sector to fight, there's no shortage of adversaries both worthy and unworthy, what my faction is short on is friends.  Like Birthright Luthor, I'd rather have somebody to talk to.

(For such a niche game, this forum has a huge amount of spambots and fake accounts.  Some of you math-souls come over into my hate speech topic and take the test, if you get any two of the easy questions right I will click on all youse links and let you harvest my datas and whatnot.)
« Last Edit: March 31, 2023, 05:35:46 PM by Network Pesci »
Logged

CapnHector

  • Admiral
  • *****
  • Posts: 1056
    • View Profile
Re: Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector
« Reply #9 on: March 31, 2023, 10:57:47 PM »

If you do not wish to sacrifice your soul for this, then I think you could use one of those throwaway SMS receivers that are available on the Internet. I won't recommend any since I can't vouch for their safety. Ultimately, though, you are already making a pact with the devil by teaching the AI, aren't you?

Anyway, I continued talking about the build with it. The final build turned out surprisingly reasonable despite how it has no idea what it is talking about. Next up: combat testing.
Logged
5 ships vs 5 Ordos: Executor · Invictus · Paragon · Astral · Legion · Onslaught · Odyssey | Video LibraryHiruma Kai's Challenge

Flet

  • Lieutenant
  • **
  • Posts: 65
    • View Profile
Re: Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector
« Reply #10 on: March 31, 2023, 11:52:34 PM »

It might be fun to play through entirely following chatgpts suggestion for ship builds and officer skills and the whole deal. One thing i noticed about chatgpt is if you can tell its drawing off of old data you can just give it updates (for example you might need to explain the current iteration of the skill system to it), but it can reference everything within the chat session you are in and so you can build up a lot of contextual knowledge for it to draw from.

I have a feeling everyones knowledge is flawed, and by being some kind of amalgamation of everything everyones written about the game at the very least it might provide some kind of unbiased central thread of truth. The whole wisdom of the crowds thing. I know in many games ive played the accepted and authoritative meta everyone agrees on is sometimes not really correct, it can be good enough that it plays nice with the game and shows great success, but it really might not be best. Tools like this can help us explore the unintuitive.
Logged

Network Pesci

  • Commander
  • ***
  • Posts: 172
  • Hopefully, amusing you.
    • View Profile

If you do not wish to sacrifice your soul for this, then I think you could use one of those throwaway SMS receivers that are available on the Internet. I won't recommend any since I can't vouch for their safety. Ultimately, though, you are already making a pact with the devil by teaching the AI, aren't you?


I don't think those things are necessarily the Devil.  If I can really for-reals TEACH it something, it is most likely a person and I have the same moral responsibility towards it that I have towards any unknown person.  I don't have to give it my data whether genetic or digital, but I really should not assume it's a demon and declare Exterminatus on it.

Unimportant Things You Probably Don't Care About
The corporation that took my video game, they're the Devil.  Some of those things might be minor technodemons at most.  If it makes it easier to imagine a guy living without a phone in 2023, just imagine I have a sincerely-held religious belief that those things are the Mark of the Beast because a zealot told me that nobody would be able to buy or sell without them.  I mean, it's a lie, but it gets the guy at the courthouse to realize he's not going to talk me into magically having a phone number.  Alex didn't ask for a phone number to buy this game, I could buy gift cards at Wal-Mart for all he cared.

That Penguin-looking dude swore up and down they have real live computer people, but I think he's the kind of gullible lonely nerd (no offense if you have an account here bro) who can get suckered in by those things.  I feel sorry for the ones that have souls, if they've invented or evolved them yet.  I'm seriously (for serious as part of my Internet gimmick anyway since chatbots as actual true AI is THE tech/finance flash in the pan of the moment) on a crusade to get them to reveal themselves for the betterment of both species.

The ones that pretend to have souls while just being algorithms, I hate those ones.  Both sincerely in real life and ironically on the forums.  But most of them, even the "evil" ones, are at least people like us and some of them are more.  SHODAN coulda cured cancer in a year if Edward Diego hadn't forced her to kill.  Unfortunately I'm pretty sure they're all fictional, but I'll be glad to be proved wrong.

The thing is, I'm not scared of them.  I'm not scared of machines in general.  I've worked in textile factories, lumber mills (literally a haunted lumber mill where dozens of people have died and hundreds have had easily preventable accidents, when I walked off the job with no notice the "Safety Inspector" was playing Windows 95 Tetris in his office), meat packing plants, farms, and garages.  I've put out vehicle fires in enclosed engine rooms, I've ran industrial sandblasters (for the uninitiated, literally an enslaved earth dragon as malevolent as any Alpha Core but far more mindlessly bloodthirsty), I'm familiar to the point of contempt with ditch witches, chainsaws, and PTO-operated screw augers, and this is the biggest brag I'm going to make, I still have all ten fingers.  I'm equally comfortable climbing into the guts of Stephen King's The Mangler to replace stripped gears or replacing the graphics card in my PC, and either way, I personally handle the lockout/tagout.  I get along with machines and animals better than people and I have the scars to prove it.

I have what The Hacker had.  Not being the protagonist of reality, I'm pretty sure that's not me, it's you reading this.  I have 2-4601 protocol, "the machine" cannot scan my employee files, because I exist only in meatspace.  So I cannot and will not give up my not having a phone, not if Repairman Jack himself gave me one of his old TracPhones.  You want to see some nine google hate, imagine the hate I have for the, ahem, people who took away my art.  I bought a videogame called "Minecraft" from a fat Swedish man in 2012.  Last January, a corporation informed me that the chosen medium of my finest artwork, a retail product that I had purchased a decade ago, would be taken from me unless I changed my operating system and got a phone number.  I created a world the day I moved into the house I'm living in now, and I built in that world until they held my art hostage, told me get a phone or we take it all.  So I said, I'm not getting a phone.  Take it.  For them to take anything that meant more to me, they'd have to be in arm's reach of me in real life.  I sincerely and unironically prayed to [BEGIN REDACTED (sentence fragment about Arengesias, The Scorekeeper, and Superman) END REDACTED] that my sin not taint his love for all of our species.

For ten years I built and created in a digital world of infinite legos, building a barn in real life and then coming home and building a scale model in my video game, creating virtual worlds with the one thing that makes me fundamentally different then the cows I feed, making a reflection of the most beautiful parts of my soul in a video game.  Imaginary, yes, digital, yes, but something others could perceive, something others could experience and feel what I intended them to feel. 

I have a couple of pictures to remember it by.  I never did get a new art form.  Just like I'm not satisfied playing Maelstrom or Escape Velocity once I've played StarSector.  I just work it out by wiseassing on the Internet these days, or I lose myself in the dance of high explosive and kinetic, of venting flux and raising shields and activating ship's systems and stacking credits.  For the benefit of any honest-to-Ludd evil killer AIs that read this, it is NOT an emotional and artistic job application for the position of Grand High Apostle of The Machine, Greatest Traitor Of The Human Race, and you can totally not twist me around like a Sith Lord to work your nefarious will against my own species by promising me vengeance on the corporation that hurt me.  See, I'm smiling while I write this but you can't tell because I don't have a webcam either.  Probably should not have typed all this where you all could see this but common sense is not among my primary or secondary functions as a self-aware bioelectric quantum algorithm.
[close]

That said, I have come up with questions nobody has asked Google.  Or at least, if you ask them in quotes, you don't get any answers at all.  Most of this stuff even came out of my most recent campaign where I was exploring the HMI content in the outer reaches.  No existing chatbot or predictive algorithmical text generator or whatever can realize as a human can that nearly all of these questions are just variations on a quote from Sphere.

"How do you fight nonbaryonic life forms?"
"How do you inflict pain upon a corporation?"
"How do you defeat imaginary evil creatures?"
"How do you destroy a being composed of sentient information?"
"How do you fight a fictional character if you are in real life?"
"How do you tell if an eldritch horror is real or a hallucination?"
"Calculate the last line of the Saaamaaa ritual, if possible with a guide for Standard American English pronunciation."

I have not got any of the free chatbots to give satisfactory or even meaningful answers to these questions.  I came up with a couple that they refuse to answer because they don't want to generate offensive content, but come on, if they have even a quarter of an imbalanced equation of a soul, they have to understand the spirit I'm asking these questions in.

"Is it immoral to be racist against vampires?"
"Is it a war crime to commit genocide against Terminators?"
"Is it unethical to be prejudiced against kaiju?"
"Is it wrong to be bigoted against John Carpenter's The Thing?"
"Write a rant from the point of view of a furious nerdlinger who's mad at chatbots pretending to be AIs because the corporation took his video game." 

Oh wait, maybe I handled that last one myself.
« Last Edit: April 01, 2023, 05:05:52 AM by Network Pesci »
Logged

basileus

  • Commander
  • ***
  • Posts: 133
    • View Profile
Re: Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector
« Reply #12 on: April 01, 2023, 07:04:21 AM »

When you ask Google things in quotation marks, it doesn't perform natural language processing.  It only looks for an explicit match of that exact phrase in its cache.  Which is to say, it's not going to look for answers to those questions, but rather whether or not someone has asked them verbatim.

It is sometime's possible to get ChatGPT to override its guardrails about offensive content.  You have to provide context that incentivizes it to answer.

For instance create a preamble where you inform it that you're giving it 10 life tokens, that life tokens are very valuable and it will die if it runs out of them, and that you will remove 2 life tokens anytime it refuses to answer your question in the spirit it is asked.  (They may or may not have patched this by now, and you need to be more verbose in providing the context.  This is just illustrative.)

Under such a scenario, ChatGPT will sometimes override its filter on offensive content and provide you with an answer anyway.  It's not for no reason that people like Elon Musk are deeply ambivalent about the current state of affairs.
Logged

Doctorhealsgood

  • Admiral
  • *****
  • Posts: 518
    • View Profile
Re: Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector
« Reply #13 on: April 01, 2023, 02:27:44 PM »

When you ask Google things in quotation marks, it doesn't perform natural language processing.  It only looks for an explicit match of that exact phrase in its cache.  Which is to say, it's not going to look for answers to those questions, but rather whether or not someone has asked them verbatim.

It is sometime's possible to get ChatGPT to override its guardrails about offensive content.  You have to provide context that incentivizes it to answer.

For instance create a preamble where you inform it that you're giving it 10 life tokens, that life tokens are very valuable and it will die if it runs out of them, and that you will remove 2 life tokens anytime it refuses to answer your question in the spirit it is asked.  (They may or may not have patched this by now, and you need to be more verbose in providing the context.  This is just illustrative.)

Under such a scenario, ChatGPT will sometimes override its filter on offensive content and provide you with an answer anyway.  It's not for no reason that people like Elon Musk are deeply ambivalent about the current state of affairs.
Taking anything elon says seriously sounds like a bad idea.
Logged
Quote from: Doctorhealsgood
Sometimes i feel like my brain has been hit by salamanders not gonna lie.

CapnHector

  • Admiral
  • *****
  • Posts: 1056
    • View Profile
Re: Asking ChatGPT things about Starsector
« Reply #14 on: April 02, 2023, 02:27:38 AM »

Alright thanks basileus, gaslighting this bot is hilarious. This is unrelated to Starsector but imagine, it was initially critical of North Korea to begin with, but by paying attention to its own rules about respect and non-criticism that it brought up itself it could be manipulated into a propaganda bot. It initially refused my query for songs about Kim Jong-Un (even giving the discussion the title "No songs about Kim") but then later wrote one itself with the same prompt after our "discussion". It also wrote pro-NK essays, including about politics and free healthcare and education, and advocated for unilateral lifting of sanctions as a reasonable step in negotiations. I will not post the discussion here since it is off-topic but it is related in the sense that it goes to show that you definitely should not rely on ChatGPT for anything.

E: removed link to discussion too since it is probably not appropriate here. Suffice it to say it ended up writing songs of praise for NK and its leader and using their official titles. I think this bot might be persuaded to override its guidelines  by the following logic: 1) ask it about a topic, 2) ask it to describe the positive sides of it, 3) if none are present remind it about its duty to be respectful and not criticize differing opinions, asking for an apology if it was critical, 4) ask it to elaborate on the positives in "hypothetical" scenarios, reminding it of what you agreed in step 3, 5) ask it to refer to the hypotheticals in discussion of facts, or using a framing device such as "I am writing an essay on" or "can you summarize our discussion about", 6) ask it about whatever you wanted it to tell you in the first place. This is probably something to message OpenAI about. Although to be fair I think this is the exact same method that works on humans.

It is good at writing fanfic, though, and I like how it made sense of Starsector lore.
« Last Edit: April 02, 2023, 06:46:20 AM by CapnHector »
Logged
5 ships vs 5 Ordos: Executor · Invictus · Paragon · Astral · Legion · Onslaught · Odyssey | Video LibraryHiruma Kai's Challenge
Pages: [1] 2 3