Want to release another bugfix patch, or is that going into .53?
When captain personalities come in 'chivalrous' should be in there. We already know what can be done to cause it~
I don't know about 'chivalrous' specifically, but I do think the general idea of captains behaving non-optimally is a good one. Historically, it's generally agreed that even the most successful naval commanders made horrible mistakes, even during battles that resulted in clear victories.
Every time a frigate dances around right outside my battleship's weapon's range, I think of World War II, when American Captains, that often had advanced search and fire-control radars, tended to close to visual range anyway, really for no logical reason.