Full assault and then I just roam around in the chaos, or usually rush the backline and spawncamp the reinforcements, or bait the backline into turning their backs to my frontline.
If not full assault then I just order Control on all objectives, but I still prefer full assault. The reason for that is because I often see my ships that would outmatch the enemy are just holding back a lot and being extremely passive, such as pushing up the flux level of the enemy ship while at low flux and then retreating and letting them to vent. I'm like "what the hell did you do that for?", and this goes on repeat in some cases until I order full assault, after which my ships eat them alive.
If it's a phase fleet I'm facing then I exhaust their CR, chasing them around isn't worth the effort. Since I don't use SO, my ships with officers can almost always win by attrition if needed. And if they don't, the enemy fleet will be too exhausted for my clean up team by that time. If it's just a few phase ships, then I order 1 frigate for each to chase them and keep them busy, I really can't be bothered with destroying them, and it works really well. They often get chased off into the corners of the map, or back into the enemy frontline. If it's a harbinger then 2 frigates. If it's a Doom, I bring out my fast disco ball.