My presently unnamed mod (Let's just call it Star Fleet Starfarer or something for right now) focuses on converting ships from the Star Fleet Battles universe into Starfarer.
Boldface mine. I haven't seen those fateful three little words together in a long,
long time.
As an ex-player of the game going back to the early 1980s, and a veteran of the late unlamented tabletob / hexmap / pencil-and-paper / WAY TOO MUCH manual bookkeeping & accounting version of the game, I have strong opinions about the game. Star Fleet Battles was a potentially great wargame in a varied and logically-consistent mythos, but it suffered
badly from autocratic management by an abrasive designer, and the then-unavoidable limitations of purely analog, handwritten data tracking & gameplay mechanics.
But seeing some SFB content freed from its various shackles and ported into a moddable game such as Starfarer?
Win.
SFB was fine for one-on-one duels or small squadron actions (3-4 ships per side), but the workload increased roughly according to the cube of the number of ships in your force. Full fleet actions greatly slowed down the game, which was a real shame as those were the kinds of fights that interested me the most. I'm at a point now in my life where I have minimal patience for the kind of rampant "rules-lawyering" that such stuff demands, and I'd rather just have Starfarer handle the mundane procedural crap while I point a Klingon B-10 battleship at Weapon Status III with all disruptors overloaded, straight towards something tasty-looking and make it go
boom.
(Haha..."boom," get it? SFB...Klingon hull design...boom section? No? Oh well.
)
There are two reasons for this - Starfleet Command 2 already has an excellent selection of models to view top/down, and Star Fleet Battles gives a good list of stats that can be translated back into Starfarer for some baseline balancing.
I agree. [-chuckle-] And if there's one thing SFB
definitely had in abundance (to put it mildly), it was stats.
BTW, if you're serious about doing a proper SFB mod for Starfarer, that green crap all over the Klingon cruiser sprite
has to go. I know that's not your fault, but here's the problem: Klingon hulls from the TOS episodes and Kirk-era movies have a light gray base hull color, and Star Fleet Battles
continues that trend fully. The sprites that Interplay created for the Starfleet Command PC game may therefore need some help to excise their own additions / tweaks / weirdness compared to the original hullforms as seen all over SFB.
You can still make ST:TSFS "Klingon Birds of Prey" green if you want, though...the original draft of the script had Romulans as the foe; got changed to Klingons; idiot f#ing writers still kept the
Romulan cloaking device on a
Klingon ship. (Grrrr!) So paint that bastard purple with orange polka-dots for all I care.
But seriously, if this is truly going to be
SFB within Starfarer -- and not merely Star Trek or Starfleet Command within Starfarer -- then these distinctions are important. Regarding additional hulls & races, I can give other advice about hull coloration, misc. physical details & etc. if you'd like; I promise not to bite. It's
your mod - I'm just an informed spectator.
As such, this mod essentially covers three eras: The Original Series (where models are applicable), X1 (first half of the film series), and X2 (second half of the film series) - each representing a leap in weapons and ship technologies.
You nailed that split between the eras. Great! [-applause-] By the way, I already tend to think of certain vanilla Starfarer units (such as Tempests) as X-ships, anyhow.
Oh
My
God
You get me models for SFB stuff and I will code the bajeezus out of them.
Now
that's enthusiasm. Looks like Durendal is firmly on-board with your mod.
Timeisaperception, if you're still in need of quality top-down images for SFB races aside from the Federation, you should do a detailed search for the artwork of Ted Geibel. IIRC, Ted no longer does that sort of thing due to a close brush with major illness, but in the 2000 to 2005-ish period he was the very best. I'll check my own archives for any usable pix of his, but I doubt that I actually saved much (if any) of them to my hard drives back then. I foolishly assumed that that sort of thing would "always be around" so I procrastinated -- I feel like an idiot for that lapse now.
Best of luck with your grand endeavour!