The Toad has been rebalanced; before this change, it dominated every fighter without a nick, and cost less to field than some of the heavier fighters. This was not my intention, and as we all know, balance is an ongoing, uphill battle. Anyways, I've kept the spirit of the Toad, which is to be a superior fighter platform in the field, for somewhat more up-front cost (12,000 CR base value), but not to be a godlike unstoppable death machine (which they were).
AFTER the balance changes, you'll notice they still win every 1-on-1 fight against any vanilla fighter... but some of these fights were extremely close. Basically they're where I wanted them originally. Slightly more powerful than vanilla, for more cash money, with in-combat fleet points of a standard heavy fighter chassis. The following log shows my in-depth trial results, and I am very pleased with the outcomes now.
nomads__balance_record__oct_2013.txt
Map size: 8000 x 8000
Fighter wing duel: 1 wing vs 1 wing
CR: 60%
Using ship_data / wing_data last modified:
2013-10-14 6:18 PM CST
---
TESTING GRID
toad 7 fp
vs
broadsword 6 fp
xyphos 7 fp
gladius 6 fp
warthog 8 fp
thunder 6 fp
talon 3 fp
wasp 5 fp
dagger 5 fp
piranha 5 fp
trident 8 fp
longbow 5 fp
mining_drone 5 fp
---
TEST RESULTS
toad vs broadsword
toad wins, 100% total hull no losses, enemy retreated with 2 lost
toad vs xyphos
toad wins, 60% total hull no losses, enemy retreated with 0 lost
toad wins, 50% total hull no losses, enemy destroyed
toad vs gladius
toad wins, 80% total hull no losses, enemy destroyed
toad wins, 20% total hull 1 loss, enemy destroyed
toad wins, 90% total hull no losses, enemy destroyed
toad vs warthog
toad wins, 45% total hull no losses, enemy destroyed
toad wins, 40% total hull 1 loss, enemy destroyed
toad vs thunder
toad wins, 100% total hull no losses, enemy retreated with 1 lost
toad wins, 98% total hull no losses, enemy retreated with 1 lost
toad wins, 100% total hull no losses, enemy retreated with 1 lost
toad vs talon
toad wins, 100% total hull no losses, enemy retreated with 3 lost
toad wins, 100% total hull no losses, enemy retreated with 2 lost
toad vs wasp
toad wins, 100% total hull no losses, enemy retreated with 1 lost
toad vs dagger
toad wins, 100% total hull no losses, enemy destroyed
toad vs piranha
toad wins, 100% total hull no losses, enemy destroyed
toad vs trident
toad wins, 100% total hull no losses, enemy destroyed
toad vs longbow
toad wins, 90% total hull no losses, enemy destroyed
toad vs mining_drone
toad wins, 100% total hull no losses, enemy destroyed