My mistake, I was mixing up the wing counts with the Gladius. Still, even at three to a squad, they just aren't worth that outrageous fleet cost. It's really hard to justify spending 10 FP on a fighter wing when the unit itself has significant limitations and another 2 points gets you a midline destroyer.
Indeed, the main faults I've seen so far with them is the FP cost and speed. If you would lower the cost to 8 FP and give it a speed of 110-120 instead of 80 I think they would be worth a slot. Of course, then we have that insane repair cost as well.
What do people think of the Torpedo Bombers? For 5 points they can put a pretty big dent into things...but then again, for 5 points I could just load up a Lasher with Atropos Racks and missile upgrades.
To be perfectly honest, I've never used them. In fact, I don't use bombers at all, not even Piranha wings. It's not that I think they're bad since I've been on the recieveing end of their bomb bays many times, but by the time they become useful to me I have already gotten a Destroyer or Cruiser to do their job. Should problably learn to use them more often though.
however, at some point you will reach a stage where it would be more beneficial to replace ships with fighters due to the fact that those ships are barely contributing to the fights either because they can't get there or the field is so saturated that they are taking more time maneuvering than they are shooting.
True, fightercraft don't have to worry about collisions which is one of the reasons they're so effective. However, due to their short range they will always have to get into melee, which is right in range of PD systems. This isn't really that big of problem though since the majority have such a high speed that when they get into too much trouble they can always fly away to the nearest carrier and repair and rearm. A nice luxury which I believe the Warthogs can't use to their fullest potential.
EDIT: basically what i said here, which is getting ignored for w/e reason: http://fractalsoftworks.com/forum/index.php?topic=3919.msg61338#msg61338
But it wasn't ignored? The same advantages that you gave the Warthog can be given to any other fighter in the game, which made me reply with the comparison with the Broadsword. Sorry if I was being unclear.